Well Pump Replacement Done Right — Free Estimates, Upfront Pricing
Old pump failing? Water pressure dropping? Tired of patching a system that’s on its way out?
From shallow jet pumps to deep submersibles — we size, install, and test your complete well pump system. Free estimate before any work begins.
Same-day installations available — call before noon.
Request Your Free Estimate
Leave your number and we’ll call within 15 minutes to schedule.
Or call us now: (434) 505-4780
Otter Guys Plumbing was great to work with. Communication was clear from the start. When Ty and Don arrived, they were kind and easy to interact with. They took the time to communicate clearly through every step: diagnosing the problem, explaining what was going on, what the potential issues were, and what needed to happen moving forward. They educated us about the situation instead of just telling us what to do. Pricing was communicated clearly the whole way through. We were given all the pricing options, what they suggested, and why. Everything felt transparent and straightforward, and we didn’t feel pressured to do more than was necessary. I would absolutely recommend them.
Why Central Virginia homeowners choose The Otter Guys
65+ years of well pump expertise across Central Virginia
Since 1960, we’ve installed and replaced well pumps throughout Central Virginia — Albemarle, Greene, Nelson, Fluvanna, Orange, and Louisa counties. Submersible, jet, constant pressure, you name it. Whatever your well system needs, we’ve done it before.
Deep well capable — submersibles to 500ft+
Not every plumber handles deep well work. We have the equipment and experience to pull and install submersible pumps at any depth. Whether you need a standard replacement or a constant pressure upgrade, we size the right pump for your well and your household.
Upfront pricing — know the total cost before we start
Your estimate includes the pump, installation labor, electrical work, and any plumbing modifications. One price, in writing. No change orders, no hidden fees, no pressure.
1-Year Service Warranty
On all well pump repairs & replacements
Licensed & Insured
VA License #2705181379
BBB A+ Rated
Accredited business
Charlottesville’s Finest
Gold Award 2023–2025
Signs it’s time for a new well pump
Pump Is 15+ Years Old
Submersible pumps last 15–25 years. If yours is aging and problems are starting, replacement is often more cost-effective than repeated repairs.
Frequent Repairs
If you’ve had two or more pump service calls in the past year, the pump is telling you something. Replacement ends the cycle of repeat repairs.
Won’t Hold Pressure
A pump that can’t maintain consistent pressure even after repair has likely reached end of life. Time for a new system.
Well Was Deepened
A deeper well may require a more powerful pump. Your old pump may not reach the new water level or deliver enough flow.
Visible Rust or Sediment
Corroded pump components contaminate your water. A new pump eliminates the source and restores clean water.
Contractor Said Replace
If another contractor condemned your pump, we’ll give you a free second opinion and honest estimate. No obligation.
Trusted by 6,000+ Charlottesville homeowners
“Scott was very pleasant, efficient and showed concern for our safety. He not only made sure we had running water throughout the house but that we were able to get my car out of the driveway before he left. Scott treated us more like family rather than just a paying customer.”Sharon O’Neill Google Review
“The Otter Guys were recommended to me by a trusted contractor for a major water leak. They found the problem and brought necessary equipment the following day, clearing the system and restoring normal function. Dylan Harris was especially helpful, explaining the problem and cost options clearly and in terms I could understand. I highly recommend their services.”Vivian Dillard Google Review
“Really really great service. I felt seen and like they were going to make sure I was fully taken care of. I had been told they were a great experience, and now have my own story to back it up.”Christy Scott Google Review
Here’s exactly what happens when you call
Site assessment
We evaluate your well depth, water table, household demand, and existing equipment. If another contractor condemned your pump, we review their findings and give you our honest assessment.
System sizing and estimate
We recommend the right pump — jet or submersible — along with the right horsepower and any upgrades (constant pressure, larger tank). You get a detailed written estimate. No pressure — it’s your decision.
Professional installation
We pull the old pump (if applicable), install the new system, connect wiring and piping, and set your pressure switch. Deep well work requires specialized equipment — we have it.
Testing and handoff
We run the full system, verify flow rate and pressure at multiple fixtures, and walk you through the new equipment. You get a warranty on parts and labor.
An old well pump doesn’t just fail — it fails at the worst possible time.
Low pressure, short cycling, and rising electric bills are warning signs your pump is on its way out. A free estimate takes about 30 minutes and tells you exactly what a new pump will cost — installed, with everything included. No obligation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Jet pump replacement (above-ground, shallow wells): typically $1,500–$3,500. Submersible pump replacement (in-well, deeper wells): typically $3,000–$8,000+. The biggest factors are well depth, pump type and horsepower, and whether you’re upgrading to a constant pressure system. Your estimate covers everything — pump, labor, electrical, and modifications. That’s why we offer it free.
Rule of thumb: if your pump is under 10 years old and the issue is electrical (pressure switch, relay, capacitor), repair usually makes sense. If the pump is 15+ years old, the motor has failed, or you’re seeing repeated problems, replacement is typically the better investment. We’ll give you an honest recommendation.
Most well pump installations are completed in one day. Jet pump replacements (above-ground) are often done in a few hours. Submersible pump replacements take longer because the old pump must be pulled from the well, but we typically finish the same day.
A constant pressure system maintains steady water pressure regardless of how many fixtures are running. Standard systems cycle on and off, which can cause pressure fluctuations. Constant pressure is an upgrade — not a requirement — but many homeowners appreciate the difference. We install both and can explain the pros and cons.
Yes. We offer 5–15 year financing plans with competitive interest rates. Most homeowners get approved in about 2 minutes. Your technician can walk you through payment options during your estimate.
Submersible pumps typically last 15–25 years. Jet pumps last 10–15 years. Lifespan depends on water quality, usage, and whether the system was properly sized. We size every pump for your specific well and household — the right pump installed correctly lasts longer.
Whether you’re dealing with an emergency replacement or planning ahead because your pump is getting old, we’ve got you covered. Over 65 years, we’ve installed thousands of well pumps across Central Virginia. Let us take this one off your plate — you don’t have to figure this out alone.